|
Unarmed black man killed in struggle
with Cincinnati police
Compiled by Seán Marquis
Dec. 9 (AGR) Community leaders in Cincinnati have called
for the local police chief to resign over the death of a black man beaten
by police.
Nathaniel Jones, 41, died at a hospital shortly after being taken into
custody Nov. 30 outside a fast food restaurant. The unarmed, 350-pound
man was struck repeatedly with nightsticks in a confrontation captured
by a video camera mounted on a police car.
Whilst defending the officers actions, the police have asked the
Justice Department and FBI to review the case.
Police Chief Thomas Streicher Jr told Cincinnati City Council that he
had invited both bodies to examine the death.
He said his officers had been defending themselves and trying to overcome
resistance to arrest.
Hamilton County Coroner Carl Parrott ruled the death a homicide, adding
that the ruling should not be interpreted as implying inappropriate
behavior or the use of excessive force by police.
Damon Lynch, head of the Cincinnati Black United Front, said the case
showed there must be change at the top of the police force.
The community-police relations in Cincinnati have been strained
for 30 years. The police officers, the chief, need to resign, retire
or be fired, Lynch said.
Coroner Parrott said Jones suffered from an enlarged heart, and that
cocaine and other drugs were found in his bloodstream.
However, the coroner said the underlying cause of death
was the struggle engaged in by an overweight man with a bad heart.
Fraternal Order of Police local president Roger Webster said At
some point, youve got to hold Mr. Jones accountable,
Webster said. These police officers are not responsible for his
death.
We are concerned about what seemed like excessive force,
the Rev. Calvin Harper, president of the Baptist Ministers Conference
of Greater Cincinnati and Vicinity said.
We also are concerned that there seems to be a rush to exonerate
the police and an attempt to assassinate the character of Nathaniel
Jones before all of the facts are in.
Kweisi Mfume, president of the National Association for the Advancement
of Colored People, also expressed concern about the use of force.
The sight of police officers repeatedly beating Nathaniel Jones
with metal night sticks is sickening and appears well outside of the
norm for subduing an unarmed suspect, said Mfume in a statement.
No one is suggesting that Jones is innocent, but neither are the
arresting officers in this instance, Mfume said.
The Citizen Complaint Authority, a city-run panel born from the riots
that followed the police shooting of an unarmed black man in 2001, is
looking into the death.
The Dec. 1 regular meeting of the complaint panel was disrupted by four
activists who demanded quick action.
Its apparent that you dont know what youre supposed
to be doing and what your authority is, said Nate Livingston Jr.,
a member of the Coalition for a Just Cincinnati, which promotes an economic
boycott of the city until the city takes concrete steps to improve race
relations and meet certain demands in regard to policing and city administration.
When they start fighting in the streets, youll say, Why
didnt you do it the right way? Why didnt you come to City
Hall? Why didnt you trust us? Why didnt you talk to us?
Police were called to escort Livingston and three others from the room
when they continued to shout at the panel.
The 2001 riots stemmed from the shooting of Timothy Thomas, 19, who
was wanted on several misdemeanor charges and fled when police tried
to arrest him. Officer Stephen Roach shot and killed him in a dark alley
and was later cleared of criminal charges.
The altercation
Emergency personnel were sent to a White Castle restaurant early Nov.
30 after a report of a man passed out on the grass.
When paramedics arrived, they found Jones and a woman, who was in some
sort of medical distress. Jones then regained consciousness and began
acting strangely. At that point, following standard procedure, the fire
officials called police.
A police videotape shows a squad car arriving at the restaurant at 5:58am,
at which point the recording device was switched off.
During the next few moments, which are not visible on tape, the two
officers from the squad car approached Jones in the parking lot of the
restaurant.
The tape resumes rolling at 6am. An officer is heard saying to Jones,
You got to tell me whats going on. Jones then says,
White boy, redneck, and the tape shows him lunging at the
officer and attempting to put him in a headlock.
At that point, the two officers both of whom are white
wrestle Jones to the ground and use their metal nightsticks, appearing
to strike him around the shoulders and torso numerous times and yelling
repeatedly, Put your hands behind your back!
Soon after, four more officers arrive, and an apparent reference to
pepper spray is heard on the tape. The view of Jones, who is being subdued
on the pavement in front of the squad car, is obscured from the camera,
which is mounted on the dashboard of the police car. At this point,
what sounds like Help! is heard coming repeatedly from the
pile of men. It becomes progressively fainter with each utterance.
A few minutes later, one officer asks for paramedics.
Hes got a pulse; hes just not breathing, the
man says of Jones.
Jones died within minutes after an ambulance took him to a hospital,
Assistant Chief Richard Janke said.
All six officers who went to the scene five whites and one black
were placed on administrative leave, which is standard procedure.
The attorney for Nathaniel Jones family, Kenneth Lawson, said
he partly blamed the police officers and paramedics for Jones
death because he believes Jones was trying to surrender when police
made him lie down.
I think, Lawson said, after you see Mr. Jones go down
and then come up on his knees on the tape, you will see... his hands
are open, his palms are open, theyre not clenched in a fist in
a fighting mode, he is trying to get into a surrender position.
Lawson also asked why 96 seconds of the police cruisers videotape
was blank. The tape begins as the cruiser heads to the restaurant, then
goes blank for 96 seconds upon arrival before capturing about six minutes
of the struggle and arrest. Chief Streicher said that the tape went
blank because the officer turned off the car, which shuts off the camera.
The officer then turned the camera on by remote control because he thought
the incident should be recorded, Streicher said.
Stun guns to save lives?
Cincinnatis mayor on Dec. 7 urged the city to buy stun guns for
its police force in response to Jones death feeling that putting
electric shock capability into the hands of every police officer will
stem the use of excessive force.
I am looking for any avenue to avoid another struggle,
Mayor Charlie Luken wrote in an e-mail to City Council members Sunday
that asked them to find $1 million in the 2004 budget to pay for the
weapons. While it is unclear whether the incident would have changed
if our officers had the latest technology in tasers, I believe we must
equip our police with the very best equipment, Luken wrote.
The newer taser models fire small, needle-like projectiles that can
shock a person who is up to 25 feet away, Luken said. The mayor said
enough money to buy 1,000 of the new stun guns for the 1,050-officer
department could come from not filling 34 middle management city vacancies
that he expects within the coming year.
Sources: Associated Press, BBC, CNN
Anti-war parents of American soldiers brave
hostility at home to see the real story in Iraq
By Phil Reeves
Baghdad, Iraq, Dec. 8 It must be strange to be Anthony
Lopercio of the US Armys 82nd Airborne Division.
The 23-year-old private has been dispatched to Fallujah to stand in
the front line on what is, for any American, one of the most hostile
places in the world. Yet, as he gazes across the dreary Iraqi landscape,
feeling the sullen resentment of its population towards foreign occupation,
he will not only be wondering about the guerrillas out there. He will
also be watching for the portly frame of his father.
Not long ago, Michael Lopercio, a 51-year-old restaurateur from Tempe,
Arizona, decided that he was not happy with the quality of the news
he was receiving about the war into which his son had been drawn. He
also realized that if the conflict dragged on, so would the amount of
time that his boy would have to remain in Iraq, where hundreds of young
Americans have already died. So he packed his bags and set off to Baghdad
to find out for himself what was happening, and to see if there was
anything he could do about it.
We havent been getting the full story in the US, he
said. The media is covering events shootings and bombings
but not the issues. They are not covering what is really happening
to Iraqi people and to the Iraqi infrastructure and how this affects
our chances of success here. Its very important to understand
the frustration of the average Iraqi and how unhappy they are with their
progress over the last eight months.
The news that his father was coming to join him in the conflict zone
was a surprise for Private Lopercio. He was utterly shocked when
I called him, said Mr Lopercio. He has yet to gain permission
to see his son but hopes it will come before he returns to the United
States this weekend.
It took five minutes to convince him I wasnt playing a practical
joke. But he was pretty excited for me. I thought he might be disapproving,
but he said he thought it would be an incredible experience for me.
His son was right. Mr Lopercio has found it incredible. Incredible that,
eight months after the invasion and occupation began, children are still
dying in Iraqi hospitals through a lack of antibiotics. Incredible that
schools have no lights, no heating, no books.
And incredible that, while he has been in Iraq this week, the occupation
authorities have staged an expensive public relations stunt by removing
the monolithic stone busts of Saddam Hussein that stood on the top of
the palace in which Paul Bremer, the chief US administrator, has his
headquarters.
Why the hell are they wasting money taking down those heads of
Saddam from the coalition authoritys palace when they could be
spending it on something more meaningful, like bringing heat and light
and medicine to Iraqi hospitals? asks Mr Lopercio. His mission
required courage, not only because of the dangers of being an American
in Iraq: his willingness to challenge his countrys reasons for
going to war, and its disastrous handling of the aftermath of the invasion,
has not gone down particularly well in Arizona.
He says conservative radio talk shows have begun attacking his wife,
a social worker, after she gave interviews to the newspapers about his
trip. They have been reading out the interviews on the air, and
giving her a hard time. Shes a little scared, and out of her element,
to be sure. He is one of a delegation of nine family members of
US soldiers and army veterans who have come to Iraq, led by the San
Francisco-based human rights group Global Exchange. Most of the group
oppose the occupation, while others say they simply want to see the
situation for themselves.
Among the group is Billy Kelly, a 60-year-old retired New York barman
who fought in Vietnam in 1967. He said: There is not a day that
goes by when I dont think about what happened there 35 years ago.
He had, he said, come to check out a suspicion that what is playing
out in Iraq has similarities to his own grim experience in uniform.
He, too, has had a hard time for his stance, not least because he is
from the city that was the principal target of the 9/11 atrocities.
Some of my friends say that Im a traitor. But I feel that
people can accept me, or not. My hope is just that there will be a dialogue
about whats going on. It hasnt happened yet. At the moment,
we have a diatribe from one side or the other.
Anabelle Valencia, from Tucson, Arizona, had tried to visit her daughter,
Giselle Valencia, who is an army truck driver stationed in Tikrit. But
she was on a mission, and not at the base.
The delegation represents an increasingly organized minority that is
willing to challenge the unremitting spin from the Bush administration
and from Downing Street as both governments seek to justify their operations
in Iraq.
Another member of the group is Fernando Suarez del Solar. His son Jesus
Alberto, a US Marine, was one of the first Americans to be killed in
Iraq the victim of an American cluster bomb. He has become a
vocal opponent of George Bushs policy in Iraq, denouncing the
invasion as illegal and demanding the immediate withdrawal of troops.
Our mission is talking to ordinary Iraqis and US troops, figuring
out why things have gone so terribly wrong and what we can do to stop
the violence and bring the troops home, he said.
The delegation has been met with a resounding lack of enthusiasm from
the US military and coalition officials. They have been
warning the media of the dangers of the visit, at the same time as trying
to persuade it that most of the country is free of violence.
None of that has deterred Mr Suarez del Solar. He has a mission: to
visit the spot where his son died and bring home a jar of the soil into
which he bled. It will be placed in a park that the boy used to visit
and marked with a white rose.
Source: Independent (UK)
Dow faces Bhopal disaster protests
Ann Arbor, Michigan, Dec. 4 Students from 25 colleges,
universities and high schools organized nationwide protests against
Dow Chemical yesterday, Dec. 3, as a part of the first-annual Global
Day of Action Against Corporate Crime. Dow Chemical, which was key manufacturer
of chemical warfare agents Napalm and Agent Orange, faced such widespread
protests for the first time since the Vietnam War due to its February
2001 acquisition of Union Carbide the perpetrator of the Bhopal
disaster. The protests, organized by Students for Bhopal, Association
for Indias Development (AID) chapters, and the Environmental Justice
Program of the Sierra Student Coalition (SSC), called on Dow to accept
its moral and legal responsibility for the worlds worst industrial
disaster.
On Dec. 3, 1984, a toxic cloud of gas from the Union Carbide plant in
Bhopal, India, enveloped the surrounding city, leaving thousands dead.
More than 20,000 have died till date and more than 120,000 people still
suffer from severe health problems as a result of their exposure. Chemicals
and heavy metals that Union Carbide abandoned at the site - including
mercury, trichloroethene, chloroform, and lead- have contaminated
the water supply for 20,000 Bhopal residents. Despite acquiring Union
Carbide, Dow Chemical has refused to address Carbides pending
liabilities in Bhopal, that include medical and economic rehabilitation
of victims, clean up of toxic wastes and contaminated groundwater, and
provision of safe drinking water. Union Carbide is a proclaimed fugitive
from justice for its failure to appear in Indian courts to face trial
for manslaughter.
Students across the country delivered samples of contaminated water
from Bhopal to the homes of eleven of Dows fourteen Board members,
including the CEO, William Stavropoulos. Although many of the deliveries
were either refused or ignored, Dr. Harold T. Shapiro, the President
Emeritus of Princeton University and an 18-year member of Dow Chemicals
Board of Directors, accepted a sample of the contaminated water following
an open talk to the Princeton community on bioethics. Dr. Shapiro also
accepted the testimonial of a Bhopal victim.
The contamination that Dow-Carbide left behind in Bhopal is their
responsibility, and it belongs in their hands, said Sujata Ray,
a member of the Princeton AID chapter that presented the water. Were
pleased that Dr. Shapiro, when faced with the consequences of his companys
inaction in Bhopal, accepted a sample of the contamination on behalf
of Dow-Carbide. Unfortunately the behavior of the other Board members
typifies that of Dow-Carbide, which continues to deny and evade their
legal and moral responsibilities in Bhopal.
Clearly, the water contamination in Bhopal is an issue that needs
to be brought home to Dow-Carbide, declared Jaimini
Parekh, an SSC member who organized a return-to-sender action
against Board member Jackie Barton. Dow-Carbide has seemed content
to condemn the survivors of Bhopal to wallow in the contamination that
it left behind. The fact that Dow-Carbide has not acted to stop the
ongoing contamination of tens of thousands for which it is responsible
is inhumane, unjust, and immoral.
Several rallies were held outside of Dow-Carbide offices and facilities,
including those in Dallas, Texas and Smithfield, Rhode Island. As during
the Vietnam War, students also protested against college affiliations
with Dow-Carbide, including recruitment, investment, and financial contributions.
Students are outraged, said Ryan Bodanyi, an organizer with
Students for Bhopal. They dont want their colleges and universities
accepting money from a corporation that maintains its profit margins
by poisoning people and blithely standing aside as they die. Dow-Carbides
callous disregard for the value of human life hasnt changed much
since the Vietnam War, and students arent going to be any more
forgiving now than they were then. Dow-Carbide should expect these protests
to continue and intensify.
Were not going to allow Dow-Carbide to get away with murder,
declared Nishant Jain, one of the leaders of AIDs Austin chapter.
Enrons crimes may have cost people their retirement portfolios,
but Dow-Carbides crimes in Bhopal have cost tens of thousands
of people their health and their lives. People are fed up with corporate
violations of our labor, environmental, and human rights, which is why
so many people have united to take action on the anniversary of Bhopal,
a particularly heinous corporate crime.
Thousands of people from sixteen countries participated in the Global
Day of Action in solidarity against Dow-Carbide and other corporate
criminals. Events and actions took place in 16 cities across India,
including Bhopal, as well as in the Netherlands, UK, USA, Lebanon, Thailand,
Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Philippines, China, Denmark, Switzerland, Spain,
Bangladesh, Canada, and Italy.
Source: Students for Bhopal
Group contests casino owned by jewish
extremist
By Jim Lobe
Washington, DC, Dec. 5 (IPS) While US Treasury officials
scour financial records worldwide to stop funds donated by wealthy Arabs
from flowing to radical Islamist groups, a small group of US citizens
is trying to shut down a major source of funding for Jewish extremists
in Israel and the occupied territories.
Its target is a gambling casino located half a world away in a tiny low-income,
mostly Latino town called Hawaiian Gardens, tucked into the urban sprawl
of greater Los Angeles.
The Hawaiian Gardens Casino has made tens of millions of dollars for its
owner, Irving Moskowitz, a 75-year-old doctor and businessman who moved
to Florida more than 20 years ago.
His Irving I. Moskowitz Foundation, which operates a bingo parlor next
door, has also produced tens of millions of dollars over the years, most
of which it passed to other charities or foundations that support the
most extreme elements in the Jewish settlement movement in Israel and
the occupied territories, according to records the foundation is required
to file with US tax authorities.
The foundation has also provided hundreds of thousands of dollars to right-wing
US Zionist groups, particularly the Zionist Organisation of America (ZOA)
and Americans for a Safe Israel (ASI), as well as neo-conservative think
tanks among them the Center for Security Policy (CSP) and the American
Enterprise Institute (AEI) that were in the forefront of the drive
to war against Iraq.
Its contribution to AEI, for example, funded the work of David Wurmser,
whose 1999 AEI book, Tyrannys Ally, argued that the ouster of former
Iraqi president Saddam Hussein was the key to remaking the Arab Middle
East.
Wurmser, who was hired as Middle East advisor to Vice President Dick Cheney
in September, acknowledged Moskowitz as his benefactor in the book, which
was prefaced by the powerful former chairman of the Defense Policy Board,
Richard Perle.
If you asked most people who Moskowitz is, they would not have any
idea, CSP director Frank Gaffney declared once at a testimonial
dinner for the man whose foundation gave CSP close to half a million dollars
between 1987 and 2001. His influence is a function of his financial
support.
It is precisely that influence that the Coalition for Justice in Hawaiian
Gardens and Jerusalem will try to curb at a hearing in Los Angeles on
Dec. 18 of Californias Gambling Control Commission. It is slated
to decide whether Moskowitz should be granted a permanent license to run
his casino, which has reportedly grossed about $180 million a year since
it began operating several years ago.
Because the casino is owned directly by Moskowitz, and not, like the bingo
hall, by a non-profit foundation, information on the destination of its
revenue is not publicly available, although his attorney has suggested
in the past that much of it goes to the same causes.
While most license hearings are pro forma affairs, this one is likely
to be contentious, as coalition members and supporters, who include Jewish,
peace and Latino groups, are lining up to testify why they believe Moskowitzs
activities, both in Hawaiian Gardens and in the Middle East, should make
him ineligible for a license.
Local activists, including former city officials, charge that Moskowitz
has essentially hijacked the municipal government to
build the casino and enrich his business interests at the expense of an
impoverished, gang-ridden community, in ways that violate both the letter
and the spirit of Californias strict gambling laws.
Moskowitzs foes who include some two dozen rabbis on the
coalitions advisory committee and the predominantly Jewish peace
group Americans for Peace Now also intend to cite his philanthropic
activities for the same basic reasons that the Bush administration is
trying to persuade Arab governments to shut down charities that fund radical
Islamists.
Knowing how he has used the bingo money to foster extremism and
violence, how can you turn around and give him a casino license?
said coalition co-director Rabbi Haim Dov Beliak, in an interview.
When you give someone a license to run a casino, youre effectively
giving him a license to print money.
Beliak, who serves two conservative Jewish congregations close to Hawaiian
Gardens, referred specifically to several Moskowitz-funded initiatives
in Israel and the West Bank, the most deadly of which the excavation
and 1996 opening of a subterranean tunnel into East Jerusalems Muslim
quarter sparked three days of rioting that killed more than 70
people, most of them Palestinian.
Moskowitz and foundations controlled by him have secretly purchased
often at highly inflated prices Arab homes in and around East Jerusalem
with the apparent intent of eventually moving in the most militant factions
of the settler movement. Similarly, he has bought tracts of property in
key zones around the city to cut off its links with Arab areas nearby.
And he has often arranged to move in settlers or begin construction on
his properties at particularly sensitive moments in Israeli-Palestinian
peace efforts, precisely in order to inflame tensions between the two
peoples, according to his critics.
In addition to any personal money he might have used to acquire these
properties, his foundation funnelled some $4 million between 1993 and
2001 for such purchases to the Miami-based American Friends of Everest
Foundation, which Moskowitz also controls, according to summaries of tax
documents obtained by the coalition and posted on its website.
Over the same period, he contributed nearly $6 million from his foundation
to the New York-based American Friends of Ateret Cohanim, a particularly
militant group that believes Jews should have exclusive control of Jerusalem
to rebuild the Old Temple on the site of one of Islams holiest mosques
and perform animal sacrifices there, and also secretly buys and then occupies
homes in the Arab quarter.
Moskowitz has also provided millions of dollars to other radical elements
of the settler movement that continue to expand their holdings in the
West Bank and the Golan Heights.
Among them is settlement Beit Hadassah, located in the middle of the West
Bank city of Hebron. Its 500 mostly youthful settlers have repeatedly
clashed with the Palestinian residents and even the Israeli Army when
it has tried to restrain them.
Beit Hadassah is itself closely linked to a much larger settlement on
the outskirts of Hebron, Kiryat Arba, the residence of Baruch Goldstein,
the US born settler who massacred 29 Palestinian worshipers at Hebrons
mosque in 1994 before being overcome and killed. His grave at Kiryat Arba
became a movement shrine.
The residents of another settlement, Beit El, located in a densely populated
Palestinian area near Jerusalem, also have a history of clashes with their
Arab neighbors, and are led by the current governments minister
of tourism, Benny Elon.
Elon, a rabbi who frequently speaks before Christian Right audiences in
the United States, is a long-time associate of Moskowitz and one of Israels
most outspoken proponents of transfer moving all Palestinians
in Greater Israel to Jordan and denying citizenship
to all those who resist moving.
Most of the millions of dollars that Moskowitz has contributed to the
settlement movement have been earmarked for religious schools that are
at the center of community life.
In many ways, a yeshiva, or beit midrash, is the counterpart of the madrassas
in the Islamic world that have served as recruitment centres for radical
Islamist movements like the Taliban in Afghanistan or even al-Qaeda
and its offshoots in recent years, according to Beliak, who was
trained in Israel.
As in the Islamic world, most schools teach a moderate and reflective
form of Judaism, while others instruct a far more radical and political
vision. Those are the ones that Moskowitz funds, Beliak said.
Students are taught that the land of Israel belongs to the Jewish
people; that it wont be fertile until Jews are in full control of
it, at which point it will respond miraculously to the presence of Jews.
Moskowitz is not supporting the people who sit and study; he funds
those that are ideologically mobilized, whose students are prepared at
any moment to take part in protests and demonstrations, and who think
it is their right to uproot olive trees on Arab land, overturn vegetable
stands in Arab markets and wreak havoc, added Beliak.
To these groups, the Oslo peace process indeed, any negotiation
that envisages the surrender of territory to the Palestinians has
been anathema. And it was from one of them that Yigal Amir, the man who
assassinated former prime minister Yitzhak Rabin in 1995, emerged.
Amir was a law student at Bar Ilan University, whose religious studies
program has been funded by Moskowitz.
Moskowitz, who had compared Rabins policies to European appeasement
of the Nazis before World War II, condemned the assassination as not
good for peace or the Jewish nation, but reportedly was more ambiguous
in a private conversation with a close childhood friend.
Remarkably, in February 2000 Israels Yedioth Aharanot newspaper
traced an internet assassination game that invited visitors
to destroy then prime minister Ehud Bartak and other pro-peace
Israeli political leaders, to Cherna Moskowitz, Irvings wife and
business partner, who also serves as an officer in his foundations.
The game, which was quickly removed after complaints were received, encouraged
visitors to click on a leaders picture, which would explode
on the screen, accompanied by the sound of screaming.
To the coalition which saved a copy of the game and its
supporters, such incitement offers further ammunition for their case that
the Moskowitzes do not meet Californias character requirements.
Indeed, they believe the Bush administration should back up their effort.
If the administration wants to be credible in demanding that Arabs
close down charities that fund radical madrassas, says Jane Hunter,
the coalitions co-director, then it should also cut the flow
of tax-free US dollars to their Jewish equivalents, the yeshivas that
Moskowitz funds.
|